Unlock the Editor’s Digest without cost
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly publication.
One of many hottest funding areas of current occasions is now feeling a bit of chilly. Earlier this yr, Lineage, an aggregator of cold-storage warehouses world wide, went public in the US elevating $4.2bn. Chilly storage had grow to be a darling of Wall Avenue with non-public credit score and infrastructure non-public fairness funds, resembling Blackstone, focusing on the sector for strong and predictable returns much less vulnerable to recessions. Lineage itself had an fascinating story, with its founders assembly as junior trainee bankers at Morgan Stanley 25 years in the past.
The pair ultimately began buying warehouses, one after the other, spending greater than $10bn in capital to create a freezer empire. Immediately, Lineage has greater than 500 services throughout the globe. It boasts an enterprise worth north of $20bn, with every of the founders billionaires.
Nonetheless, shares of Lineage are down 1 / 4 from their summer season IPO value. Shares in rival Americold have additionally cooled, down 29 per cent for the yr. Instantly, these supposedly steady toll collectors that Wall Avenue likes to tout don’t look so dependable.
Lineage is organised as an actual property funding belief (Reit), a construction that avoids company tax so long as most earnings are paid out to shareholders as dividends. The corporate’s thesis is that chilly storage has traditionally been fragmented and that centralised possession may create efficiencies that had not existed earlier than. With rising incomes and dwelling requirements, meat and seafood consumption will rise over time, making a consolidation alternative. And whereas Lineage is concentrated on meals, chilly storage for all times sciences has additionally attracted investor {dollars}.
Chilly-storage services prospered within the wake of the pandemic, however the enterprise has grow to be trickier in 2024. Meals corporations and grocery shops are rationalising inventories that had constructed up amid 2020 and 2021 supply-chain snarls and elevated buyer demand. Third-quarter income development at Lineage was basically flat yr on yr. And even after the share value slide, Lineage’s EV/ebitda a number of is round 17 occasions with a dividend yield of a modest 3.6 per cent, suggesting further draw back stays.
Infrastructure enterprise fashions are designed to compound earnings and money move over a protracted cycle and so the short-term struggles at Lineage might not be consequential. It might be that lending to such companies, somewhat than proudly owning fairness, proves the higher risk-adjusted punt. However when excessive finance finds a sizzling asset class, the pile-in inevitably depresses future returns.
